Names are more than just words. They give us a sense of identity and locality, and commemorate cultural and historical connections. Carlton has a rich history of names - from the names that appear on the parapets of individual houses or groups of houses in a terrace, through to laneways, streets, parks, and the suburb itself. Naming conventions are now strictly regulated, with significant rules that a place should not be named after a living person or an existing business or organisation, and that duplication of names should be avoided. It was a different situation in the 19th century. In the early days of Carlton, streets were routinely named after British dignatories and prominent citizens. A few decades on, in the 1870s and 1880s, Melbourne City councillors were rewarded with street names upon their retirement. John Curtain, Member of Parliament and Melbourne City Councillor, had both the reserve know as Curtain Square and the adjacent street named after him.1,2,3
House names open up a whole new area of naming rights. Some houses, such as Westray Villa in Canning Street, have a demonstrated connection with the original owner, while others were named at the whim of the builder. Themes are common for a row of houses by the same builder: Floral themes such as "Daphne, Violet and Pansy" and the shipping themes "Suevic, Afric and Runic". Houses were sometimes named after the street in which they were built and, as the house names were not regulated, there was some duplication within the same suburb. For example, there was once a short street named Rathdowne Terrace off the southern end of Rathdowne Street, and a more substantial terrace of three double storey houses, with the same name, just a few blocks away.
The origins of many of these names have been lost in history and are often the subject of speculation. Carlton Community History Group acknowledges the importance of place and house names as part of our heritage and we are documenting these from available sources. Contact us if you can contribute to this important line of research.
Notes and References:
1 Naming rules for places in Victoria : Statutory requirements for naming roads, features and localities. Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning, 2016
2 Street Names
3 The Age, 25 April 1876, p. 3
The Name of the Prince
North Carlton has three princely locations - Princes Hill, Princes Park and Princes Street. CCHG has recently been asked to research the naming of Princes Hill, the area north of Macpherson Street and west of Lygon Street. Our investigations have turned up several contenders for naming rights, all members of British royal family from the nineteenth century.
The online Encylopedia of Melbourne attributes the naming of both Princes Park and Princes Hill to Prince Albert of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha, the consort of Queen Victoria. Only one reference is cited - Prinny Hill : The State Schools of Princes Hill 1889-1989 - and this book, in turn, gives a different interpretation.1
Prinny Hill attributes the naming of both Princes Park and Princes Hill to Prince Alfred, the Duke of Edinburgh and son of Queen Victoria. Prince Alfred came to Victoria in November 1867 and is claimed to have visited the area that became Princes Hill, but was this location the same as Princes Hill the suburb? There are several newspaper references to "Prince's Hill" and "Princess Hill" dating back the 1860s and one published in 1867, the same year as Prince Alfred's visit, refers to "… the waste ground adjacent to Prince's-bridge, lying between the river bank and the Prince's-hill reserve ..." This reference, and others from 1861, place "Prince's Hill" in the vicinity of the Yarra River and Prince's Bridge, for which it most likely named. (Prince's Bridge, which opened in 1850, was named after Albert, the Prince of Wales.) 2,3,4,5,6,7
Prince Alfred's royal visit does not fit within the time fame for Princes Park. The area named as "Prince's Park" appeared on the Kearney map of 1855 and the land was permanently reserved in August 1864, three years before Prince Alfred's visit. So Prince Alfred is no longer a contender for the naming of Princes Park, but he could still be in the running for Princes Hill.
Prince Albert Victor and Prince George of Wales
Prince Albert Victor and Prince George of Wales visited Victoria in June and July of 1881. They were Queen Victoria's grandchildren, and sons of Albert Edward, the Prince of Wales and heir to the throne. Albert Victor died in 1892, and his younger brother George was later crowned King George V, following the death of their father King Edward VII. The timing of their visit pre-dates the naming of Princes Hill by at least two years, and post-dates the renaming of Reilly Street to Princes Street. Timewise, the two princes could be contenders for the naming of Princes Hill, but they miss out on Princes Street.8
Albert Edward, Prince of Wales
Wikipedia gives an unreferenced statement that Princes Hill was named after the Prince of Wales. During Queen Victoria's reign, her eldest son Albert Edward was Prince of Wales and he became King Edward VII following her death in 1901. Also according to Wikipedia, Prince's Park in Liverpool, England, was named after the Albert Edward (born in 1841) when it opened in 1842. It is possible that Prince's Park (and hence the suburb of Princes Hill) was named after the Prince of Wales but, in the absence of any documentary evidence, this is pure speculation.9
Princes Park and Princes Hill
The area named Princes Park appears on the Kearney map of 1855 and in 1856 The Argus describes the park as:
"… another fine piece of thickly-wooded land, separated from the former [Royal Park] by the Sydney road which, from the commencement of the parks to the Brunswick turnpike, runs between an avenue of splendid trees. This park extends on the other side to the Merri Creek and quarries. The availability of this park is impaired by its being open from the Sydney road, and traversed in all directions by cart-tracks."10
Digitised Image: State Library of Victoria
Portion of the Kearney Map of 1855
Showing location of Prince's Park, the Cemetery, the Stockade Reserve and Smith Ward.
Reilly Street (lower right hand corner) was later extended into Carlton and renamed Princes Street, circa 1880.
By the time the land was permanently reserved in August 1864, Prince's Park had been reduced to 84 acres, between Sydney Road to the west and the Cemetery and Princes Park Road on the east. The loss of parkland to the east and north of the cemetery was most likely done with a view to releasing crown land for future residential development. This happened in November 1869, when the new Victoria Ward was created from the northern portion of the existing Smith Ward. Crown land on the east side of Lygon Street north of Reilly Street was first released in 1870, and the area immediately north of the cemetery, which later became Princes Hill, in 1875.11,12,13
In July 1883, The Age and The Argus reported that a deputation of residents approached the Mayor of Melbourne requesting the area behind the cemetery to be named Prince's Hill. The proposal was positively received, as it did not involve the renaming of existing streets, and the seed of Prince's Hill as a suburb was planted.
PROPOSED PRINCE'S-HILL SUBURB.
An influential deputation of residents of North Carlton, accompanied by Crs. Richardson, Leonard and Alderman O'Grady, waited upon the Mayor of Melbourne, at the Town Hall, yesterday, to request that that part of North Carlton, at the back of the General Cemetery, should be definitely named. Mr. Gardiner, M.L.A., was also present. It was pointed out that the designation, "at the back of the cemetery," was not agreeable to the ratepayers, and they asked that the locality should be named Prince's-hill. Mr. Dodgshun, in reply, said that if the deputation would forward to him their wishes in writing it would be brought before the City Council at its next meeting, when, as the names of the streets would not be interfered with, he had no doubt the wishes of the deputation would be granted.14,15
The phrase "should be definitely named" is interesting and suggests that the name Prince's Hill may already have been in informal use prior to the deputation, and Council approval was a foregone conclusion. The proposal was considered at a Council meeting on 23 July 1883 and referred to the Public Works Committee. By October 1883, the name Prince's Hill began to appear in Council minutes and in real estate advertisements, as distinct from the suburb of North Carlton. Both suburbs remained within Victoria ward. The apostrophe was later dropped from the names of both Prince's Park and Prince's Hill, probably for the convenience of signwriters and typesetters. However, the misnomer "Princess Hill", which sometimes appeared in newspapers in the early days, still persists today.16,17
The question of which prince gave his name to a suburb thousands of miles away from his home country is still open. Princes Hill has close historical and geographical links with Princes Park, as the area north of the cemetery was once part of the same park. The suburb may well have been named after Princes Park, in which case Prince Albert and his son Albert Edward could be rivals for the naming rights. Prince Alfred's visit of 1867 does not fit into the time frame for the naming of either Princes Park or Princes Hill. The younger Princes - Albert Victor and George - may have some claim to the naming of Princes Hill (but not Princes Park) in terms of the timing of their visit in 1881.
None of these claims is supported by firm documentary evidence and CCHG is seeking your help. Contact us if you can shed any light on the naming of Princes Hill.
Notes and References
1 Brian Carroll. Princes Hill, Encylopedia of Melbourne
2 Nicholas Vlahogiannis. Prinny Hill : The State Schools of Princes Hill 1889-1989, p. 5
3 The Age, 30 November 1867, p. 5
4 The Argus, 6 March 1867, p. 4
5 The Herald, 29 October 1861, p. 6
6 The Argus, 3 December 1861, p. 6
7 Port Phillip Gazette and Settler's Journal, 21 March 1846, p. 2
8 Melbourne and its suburbs, 1855 (Kearney map)
9 Victoria Government Gazette, no. 77, 2 August 1864, p. 1670
10 The Argus, 25 June 1881, p. 8
11 Wikipedia is a wonderful resource, but the information content is variable in accuracy and subject to revision. The entries for Princes Hill and Prince's Park (Liverpool) were accessed 5 March 2019.
12 The Argus, 8 February 1856, p. 4
13 Victoria Government Gazette (see note 5 above)
14 Victoria Government Gazette, no. 61, 5 November 1869, p. 1767
15 Parish Plan of Jika Jika, M314 (14) and land title records.
16 The Age, 12 July 1883, p. 7
17 Minute Books of Council Meetings, 1883, p. 509 and 568 (VPRS 8910)
Barry versus Barry
Barry Street and Barry Square
Sir Redmond Barry, the judge who famously sentenced Ned Kelly to death by hanging, had a long association with Carlton. He was the original crown land owner of two adjoining allotments in Rathdowne and Pelham Streets in 1853, and he lived in Carlton until the mid-1870s, when his substantial house was acquired and re-purposed as the new Hospital for Sick Children. Redmond Barry was appointed the first chancellor of Melbourne University in 1854, a position he held until his death in 1880. He was laid to rest in Melbourne General Cemetery, Carlton. The Victorian Heritage Database (B2376) attributes the naming of Barry Square in Carlton to Redmond Barry. However another, much younger, contender for the naming rights has emerged. The website Multifaceted Melbourne states that Barry Square was named after Daniel Joseph Barry, a Queensland soldier who was killed in action in World War 1 in October 1918, and that University Square was named as recently as 1998. Does this stand up to fact checking? 1,2,3,4
The crown grant, dated 13 June 1873, for the area bounded by Grattan, Leicester, Pelham and Barry Streets refers to "a public ground known as University Square". This name was in use as early as the 1860s, when it was common to name reserves according to their locality, hence "Barry Square" after Barry Street on the western boundary or "University Square" after the University of Melbourne on the northern boundary. Other examples in Carlton include Argyle Square and Macarthur Square, where the street names were used interchangeably with the names of the squares. This all took place decades before Daniel Joseph Barry was born in 1894 and more than a century before Barry Square was purportedly renamed University Square in 1998. So Daniel Joseph Barry's claim to naming rights does not fit within the established time frame. 5,6
Who was Daniel Joseph Barry? According to his service record (NAA: B2455, BARRY D J), he was born at California Creek, Herberton in Queensland in November 1894 and he was working as a clerk at the time of his enlistment. He enlisted at Townsville in October 1916 and was a private in the 7th Machine Gun Company and later the 2nd Machine Gun Battalion. Private Daniel Joseph Barry was killed in action in France on 3 October 1918, a young life cut short a month before his 24th birthday. In the months following his death, his family sought information about his final resting place. Months stretched into years and in May 1923 the Officer in Charge of base records wrote advising, with regret, that Grave Services had not succeeded in locating Private Barry's remains. The only consolation to the family was that Barry's name, regimental description and date of death would appear on a collective memorial to the fallen, to be "erected in certain defined battle areas of France or Belgium". There is no evidence in Private Barry's service record that his name was memorialised in Barry Square, Carlton, or that he had any known connection with the reserve in Carlton. 7
What would Judge Redmond Barry have made of this evidence? He certainly had a prior claim to the naming rights of Barry Street and Barry Square, in terms of both timeline and his connection with Melbourne University. Unlike the present day naming conventions, it was common to have streets and other landmarks named after prominent citizens during their lifetime. Redmond Barry's claim is backed up by evidence from authoritative sources, such as the Victorian Heritage Database, Melbourne City Council and Melbourne University. By contrast, Daniel Barry's claim consists of an unsupported statement on a web page that is now closed for comments. The verdict comes down in favour of Redmond Barry, but CCHG would be interested to hear of any information in support of Private Barry's claim.8,9
For more information on the squares of Carlton - Argyle, Curtain, Lincoln, Macarthur, Murchison and University - see our August 2018 newsletter.
Notes and References:
1 Australian Dictionary of Biography
2 The Argus, 28 September 1876, p. 7
3 Victorian Heritage Database (B2376)
4 Multifaceted Melbourne 5 Certificate of Title, Vol. 600, Fol. 912 (13 June 1873)
6 Argyle Square and Macarthur Square were permanently reserved on 13 June 1873, the same date as University Square.
7 NAA: B2455, BARRY D J (National Archives of Australia)
8 University Square Timeline 9 Melbourne University Key 13: Grounds and Buildings
Wicklow House and Vale of Avoca
41 and 43 Macarthur Place Carlton
41 Macarthur Place Carlton
Notes and References:
1 The street names "Macarthur Place" and "Macarthur Square" have been used interchangeably over time, but the official name is now "Macarthur Place" for the street and "Macarthur Square" for the reserve area in the centre. The land of Macarthur Square was permanently reserved from sale in 1873.
2 Pioneer Index. Victoria 1836-1888
3 The Argus, 22 September 1888, p. 1
4 Probate File 38/278, 1888 (VPRS 28)
5 Certificate of Title, Vol. 1226, Fol. 184
6 The original cottage dates back to the early development of Macarthur Place in the 1860s.
7 Melbourne City Council Rate Books, Victoria Ward, 1883-1888
8 Notice of Intent to Build, Reg. no. 3948, 1889 (VPRS 9463)
9 Avoca is the name of a town and river in County Wicklow, Ireland.
10 Factories and Shops Act Prosecution, The Argus, 28 April 1898, p. 3
11 Building occupancy information sourced from Sands & McDougall and Electoral Rolls
12 Family Notices, The Argus, 31 March 1927, p. 1
13 Probate File 213/796, 1927 (VPRS 28)
14 Certificate of Title, Vol. 1524, Fol. 699
The Prettie Houses of Macarthur Place
Foundation stones are a common sight in public and institutional buildings, but less so in private residences. "Wicklow House" and its neighbour "Vale of Avoca", located at 41 and 43 Macarthur Place Carlton, have foundation stones with the wording:
THIS FOUNDATION STONE WAS LAID 30 JULY 1889 BY K.M. PRETTIESo who was K.M. Prettie? Kate Prettie, as she was later known, was born Catherine Mary Downey in Cork, Ireland. In 1883, she married fellow Irishman John Prettie, born in Tipperary. John was a restaurant keeper, and he and Kate lived on their restaurant premises in Bourke Street, Melbourne, on the corner of Brien Lane. John died on 21 September 1888 aged 40 years and, at the time of his death, he owned real estate in Wilson Street, Prahran, and Canning Street, Carlton.1,2,3,4
On 20 December 1883 Mrs Prettie acquired a property, previously owned by Helena Moran, in Macarthur Place South. Rate book records confirm that a four room brick cottage, then numbered 32 Macarthur Place, was on the site measuring 29 ft by 60 ft. The cottage was rented out for the next few years, then in June 1889 Mrs Prettie lodged a Notice of Intent to build two houses, designed by architect De Garis & Son and built by Thomas Roscoe of Lee Street, North Carlton. The house names "Wicklow" and "Vale of Avoca" reflected Kate's Irish heritage.5,6,7,8,9
The new houses continued as rental properties and Kate stayed on at the Bourke Street restaurant until 1898. In the same year, waitress Alice Rawlins took legal action against Kate for employing her for more than 60 hours per week. Mr. Nicolson of the District Court considered that the complainant was not sufficiently corroborated and dismissed the case without costs. It was also noted that the defendant, Mrs Prettie, could not exercise full supervision at the time due to incapacity. Kate would have been in her late forties at the time and health issues may have influenced her decision to leave the restaurant business. She took up residence at 43 Macarthur Place with her brother James Downey, while 41 Macarthur Place was rented out.10,11
Kate Prettie died at her home in Macarthur Place on 29 March 1927, aged 75 years. In her will dated 20 November 1923, she left her properties at 41 and 43 Macarthur Place to the Little Sisters of the Poor in Northcote. However, she made specific provision for her brother James to retain the properties "for his own use and benefit" during his lifetime. Her will also made provision for her tenant, Mrs Dora Morcomb, to stay at 41 Macarthur Place for a set rent not exceeding 15 shillings per week. James Downey died on 15 October 1934, aged 83 years, and ownership of the properties was transferred to the Little Sisters of the Poor in July 1936.12,13,14
Westray VillaFrom the Orkney Islands of Scotland
248 Canning Street, North Carlton
Westray Villa in Canning Street, North Carlton, was the home of the Cormack family from the 1880s through to 1960. To explore the origin of this house's name, we travel back to a remote island off the coast of Scotland and follow the journey of a young woman who made a life-changing – and almost life-threatening – choice in the mid-19th century. Phoebe Papley (Paplie) was born in 1833 (or 1834) at Westray in the Orkney islands of Scotland. Westray, while not the smallest of the Orkney islands, is only 18.2 square miles or 47 square kilometres in area and, in the 19th century, would have offered limited opportunities for earning a living and supporting a family. Phoebe was the daughter of James Papley and Barbara (Barbra) Skee (Skea, Skae or Skay) and the Scotland census of 1841 recorded four residents in the household at Dogtua (Dogtuan) as:
Name Age Birth Year Birth Place Barbra Paplie 45 years 1796 Orkney, Scotland Febey Paplie 8 years 1833 Orkney, Scotland Jane Paplie 5 years 1836 Orkney, Scotland Mary Paplie 40 years 1801 Orkney, Scotland
In the 1851 census Phoebe was no longer listed as living at Dogtua. In the same census year, a young woman named "Phoebe Pably", aged 18, was recorded as a servant living in the household of Stewart and Mary Logie at Ark House in Westray. A year later, in 1852, Phoebe left her island home to embark on an eventful journey to a new life in Australia. She was described in the passenger list as a domestic servant of the Presbyterian religion and, unlike many of her fellow passengers, she could read and write. Phoebe was not alone on the voyage, as her older brother James, sister-in-law Jessie (Janet) and their two children, also named James and Jessie, were on the same ship. Phoebe's name appears on a different page of the shipping list, suggesting that she was housed separately in the single women's quarters, in line with ship boarding practices at the time.1,2,3,4,5
The Papleys were among an estimated 795 Scottish, English and Irish passengers and 48 crew aboard the ill-fated emigrant ship Ticonderoga. The American-built ship was fitted out to maximise the number of passengers carried and, while there was sufficient food on board for 120 days, there was no provision for the ship to take on fresh food and water during the non-stop voyage. The Ticonderoga sailed from Liverpool on 4 August 1852 and arrived at Port Phillip Heads 3 months later on 3 November, flying the yellow "plague" flag. The double-deck ship was overcrowded and unsanitary conditions on board led to the rapid spread of disease, reported as scarlet fever and the even more deadly typhus fever. 100 passengers died during the voyage and were buried at sea. The ship was denied entry to Port Phillip Bay and the passengers – the living, the dead and the dying – were offloaded at a remote beach near Point Nepean. Having endured three months at sea in appalling conditions, the survivors now faced an indeterminate period of quarantine until the disease had run its course. For Anglo-Celtic people accustomed to a colder climate, the first glimpse of their new home with its strange coastal vegetation would have been bleak. A makeshift camp of tents was set up, but this offered little protection from the hot Australian sun and the inevitable flies. Once the news of the Ticonderoga's plight had reached Melbourne, supplies of fresh food and medicine were despatched to Point Nepean. The hulk Lysander was fitted out as a hospital ship to accept the more serious cases, many of whom died. The dead were buried, often by their grieving relatives, in the sandy soil and their graves were marked by rough stone or wooden markers. The official death toll was 168 passengers and 2 crew, but it is thought to be higher as some deaths went unreported. The Papleys survived and arrived at Hobson's Bay, just before Christmas, on 22 December 1852, nearly five months after their departure from Liverpool.6,7,8
James Papley, an agricultural laborer, was engaged by William Gillespie, a tailor, of Belfast (an early name for Port Fairy) and he headed off to work in the western district in January 1853. There was a demand for workers as many had abandoned their posts to seek their fortunes on the goldfields. James and his wife Jessie had three more children – two sons named Robert in 1854 and 1857, the first of whom died in 1855, and William in 1859. When the new Belfast Hospital and Benevolent Asylum was opened in 1856, James and Jessie Papley were appointed as Master and Matron. There were concerns expressed about their suitability for the positions, particularly in relation to Mrs Papley, and allegations were made of mismanagement of inmates and financial resources. They were dismissed in 1858, then re-instated to the positions, which they held until 1871, when Mr and Mrs Mainwaring were appointed. The Papley's reputation was not enhanced by an allegation of indecent assault in 1869, involving their teenage son James and Phoebe Mott, a servant at the hospital. The incident and subsequent inquiry were considered of sufficient importance to be published in the Melbourne newspapers.9,10,11,12
If even a portion of what the Banner of Belfast states concerning the local hospital be true, the hospital committee would appear to be very lenient in discharging their duty, to say the least : – "We learn that the committee appointed to investigate the charge made by the girl Mott have virtually shelved the case. We are also informed that notwithstanding that the committee were specially instructed to inquire into the general management of the hospital, no such inquiry was made ; on the contrary, that those anxious to do so were obstructed. From the time of this occurrence there seemed a very anxious desire to hush it up, and the girl was prevented laying a [sic] criminal information against Papley. In her subsequent statement she does not accuse him of any criminal intent, but this was after certain influences were exerted to silence her. If she had been of that opinion at first, why go to the police court to lay informations [sic] against Papley? Papley's statement that the affair was a 'lark' is not worthy of belief. Neither is it consistent with his statement that he was about to destroy himself because his father had compelled him to go to Mr Burnett's revival meeting, where he met the girl Mott. If the committee believed that statement they would have had him arrested as a dangerous lunatic. There can be no doubt that the girl was tampered with, from the discrepancy between her written statement and that made by her at the police office. That the committee stood between the culprit and the law – that they burked the inquiry into the general management of the hospital – is proof sufficient that the investigation was a mere sham. To delay inquiry for three weeks, until the matter was quietly arranged, looked also like a pre-determination to hush up the affair."
Phoebe Papley's first few years in Australia are unknown - she may have gone to Belfast with James and his family, or she may have stayed in Melbourne and obtained a position as a domestic servant. In 1856, Phoebe had another life-changing event when she married a fellow Scot named William Cormack. William, born in Wick, Caithness, in 1825, was a tailor by trade and the 1841 Scotland Census confirms that he was an apprentice at the age of 15. According to Victorian birth and death records, William and Phoebe had eight (possibly nine) children. The first recorded birth was Barbara Jane in 1857, followed by Rachel in 1858. There was an unrecorded birth of a daughter named Phoebe and, working back from her age at death, her year of birth would have been circa 1857, the same as Barbara. As there is no further record of Barbara, it is possible that she was re-named Phoebe. The next daughter, Jane, did not live to her first birthday. She was born in 1861 and died in December of the same year. Then came two sons, William Donald in 1862 and James Robert in 1865, and another daughter Jessie Elizabeth in 1868. Two more sons, George Alexander and John Papley, were born in 1870 and 1872, but George died in 1874 at the age of 4. The family lived in a three room brick house in Faraday Street, Carlton, and William Cormack also owned the adjoining house, which was rented out. (At the time, the houses were numbered 85 and 87, but were changed to 110 and 112 Faraday Street in the late 1880s.) Young Phoebe must have wandered from home in May 1860, when Mr Cormack placed an advertisement in the public notices of The Argus for a lost child. It may seem strange to advertise a lost child in the same manner as you would a lost animal, but child supervision standards were different in the 19th century compared to those of today.13,14,15,16,17
"LOST, a GIRL, three years old. Had on a man's cloth cap, polka jacket, and stripe pinafore; Name Phoebe. Address Mr. Cormack, 85 Faraday-street, Carlton.
By the 1870s, the Cormack family was rapidly out-growing the three room house in Faraday Street and in the same decade land allotments became available in the new suburb of North Carlton. The prison stockade had closed in 1866 and the lunatic asylum, which replaced it, closed in 1873. The old asylum site was taken over by the Education Department and a new school (originally called the Stockade School and now Carlton North Primary School) opened in July 1873, encouraging families with children to move into the area. One of the early crown land owners was George Williams of Carlton, who bought four allotments in section 86, the area bounded by Canning, Yorke (later Lee) and Station Streets in 1870. He paid £280 for allotment 4, containing 1 rood and 12⅖ perches. The crown allotment originally stretched all the way back to Station Street but, after subdivision, the block of land purchased by William Cormack in 1880 measured 17 feet 6 inches wide by 102 feet deep. In the same month the land purchase was registered, October 1880, a notice of intent was lodged by John Wright – a builder of Lygon Street, Carlton – for a five room cottage in Canning Street. The owner's name is recorded as "Cormick" and, given the street location and coincidental dates, this construction was quite possibly Westray Villa. The new house first appears in the Melbourne City Council rate books in 1881 and is described as a "four-roomed brick house with verandah and bathroom". From 1889, there were indications that the house had been extended because room count had increased to eight.18,19, 21,22,23
In 1891, Phoebe participated in a significant event that had far-reaching implications for generations of women who followed her. The so-called "Monster" petition in support of the vote for women records three signatories at the address of 248 Canning Street, North Carlton – J. Cormack, P. Cormack and Mrs Cormack. The first signature was most likely Phoebe's daughter Jessie and the second Phoebe junior. The petition was tabled in the Parliament of Victoria in September in 1891, but it was not until 1902 that women were allowed to vote in Commonwealth elections and 1908 in Victorian elections. The Commonwealth electoral roll for 1903 lists five registered voters living at Westray Villa. Jessie was unmarried and still living at home, together with her mother Phoebe and her brothers James, John Papley and William Donald Cormack.24,25,26
Name Address Occupation Cormack, James 248 Canning Street, North Carlton Plasterer Cormack, Jessie 248 Canning Street, North Carlton Home duties Cormack, John Papley 248 Canning Street, North Carlton Clerk Cormack, Phoebe 248 Canning Street, North Carlton Home duties Cormack, William Donald 248 Canning Street, North Carlton Weigher
Tragedy struck Westray Villa in 1897. Phoebe was no stranger to death – she had witnessed the events on board the Ticonderoga and she had lost two of her own young children – but the loss of another daughter and her husband, within months of each other, was almost too much for a wife and mother to bear. Her daughter Phoebe died at home on 15 April, aged 39 years, and was buried on Good Friday of 1897. Seven months later, on 1 November, her husband William died. According to his probate documents he died intestate (without leaving a will) and it was some years before his estate was finally wound up. His main asset, according to the documents, was the house in Canning Street, valued at £475, and furniture valued at £15. No money or personal items were recorded. Letters of administration (in lieu of probate) were granted to Phoebe, with a note signed by her in March 1901 stating "The house and land in Canning Street is still retained by me. That being the only asset in the estate." However, Phoebe's name does not appear as proprietor on the certificate of title and her husband's estate was not duly administered until 1920. Phoebe had a place to live, but she may have had little in the way of financial assets. Her financial situation could possibly explain a curious advertisement that appeared in The Age in October 1900.27,28,29
MRS. Power has accommodation for ladies expecting; terms moderate : doctor in attendance. Westray Villa, 248 Canning-st., N. Carlton.
At the time, it was not uncommon for maternity services to be offered in private houses. Mrs Power may have been a registered nurse, or an experienced midwife, and the attendance of a doctor was likely to inspire confidence in her services. Phoebe may have, through financial necessity, rented out one or more of the eight rooms in the house to Mrs Power for maternity purposes.
Phoebe Cormack signed her last will and testament on 6 November 1900, leaving her estate in equal shares to her children William Donald, James Robert, Jessie Elizabeth and John Papley Cormack. Phoebe's address stated in the will was 457 Canning Street, North Carlton, though her name continued to be listed as the occupier of 248 Canning Street in Sands & McDougall directories. For some reason, Rachel was not named in Phoebe's will. Rachel died in February 1914 and her mother Phoebe a few weeks later at Westray Villa, aged 80 years. Her death notice appeared in The Age of 21 March 1914.30,31,32
CORMACK. On the 13th March, at her residence, 248 Canning-Street, North Carlton, Phoebe, widow of the late W. Cormick. A colonist of 60 years.
Interred privately Saturday, 14th. A patient sufferer at rest. Deeply regretted.
Eight months later, Phoebe's brother James Papley died in Portland, aged 88 years. That Phoebe and James cheated death on the Ticonderoga and both lived into their eighties is a testament to the strong constitution of their Westray ancestors.
"In a recent issue we recorded the death of Mr James Papley, senior, of Narrawong, which occurred at his son's residence, Percy-street, Portland, on September 25, and whose remains were interred in the Narrawong cemetery on the Sunday following, the funeral being largely attended. The deceased, who was 88 years old, was a very old colonist, he having arrived in Australia in the year 1852 in the ship Tyconderoga [sic] from Orkney Island, Scotland. He and his wife took the position of master and matron of the first Port Fairy hospital, which they held for a number of years. He afterwards took to farming in the Narrawong district, where he lived for 43 years. Deceased leaves three sons, a number of grandchildren, and great grandchildren." 33
Phoebe's estate was valued at £208, 6 shillings and 8 pence, with the amount £158, 6 shillings and 8 pence listed as "interest in a deceased person's estate." This was equivalent to a one third share of her husband's real estate, valued at £475 in 1898. Probate was granted to her elder sons William Donald Cormack and James Robert Cormack. At the time of Phoebe's death in 1914, her husband William's estate had not been duly administered – she may have simply omitted to complete the paperwork – and this generated a second application for letters of administration in 1920. William Donald Cormack, the eldest son of William and Phoebe Cormack, applied for "administration of the unadministered estate" of his father in August 1920. In the application he states that the house, then valued at £680, was occupied by his sister Jessie Elizabeth Cormack, his brothers James Robert Cormack, John Papley Cormack (crossed out) and himself. His explanation for the time delay in application was that he was not aware of the requirement until he consulted his solicitors.34,35
James Papley junior's son Leonard was killed in action at Gallipoli in 1915 and, two years later, James died in Portland in 1917. His obituary, published in Port Fairy Gazette, stated that he was born in the Orkney Islands and came to Australia as an infant:
"Mr James Papley, an old and respected resident of Portland, died on Sunday morning last, after a brief illness. He was born at the Orkney Is. in 1852, and came to Australia with his parents in his infancy. His father was superintendent of the Port Fairy hospital for some time, and afterwards took up farming at Narrawong. Deceased was a carpenter and joiner by trade, and carried on business at Portland up to the time of his death. He held a seat for a short term on the hospital board, and was a member of the cemetery trust. He leaves a widow, two sons (Fred and William) and three daughters (Maisie, Eileen and Kathleen) to mourn his loss. One of his sons (Leonard) was killed at Gallipoli a few days after the memorable landing, and his daughter Alma died a few months ago. The funeral left All Saints' R.C. church on Tuesday for the South Cemetery." 36,37
Phoebe's younger sister Jane Papley, a needlewoman and dressmaker, migrated to Australia in later life and she died in Camberwell in 1923 at the age of 85 years, once again a testament to the Papley family's longevity. She was buried in the Cormack family grave in Melbourne General Cemetery. Death visited the Cormack family again in 1928, with the uncanny repetition of two funerals within a few months of each other. Jessie Elizabeth Cormack died at home, aged 61 years, followed by her brother James Robert Cormack, aged 64 years, at a private hospital in Fitzroy. Ownership of Westray Villa was transferred to the two surviving Cormack brothers, William Donald and John Papley. William Donald Cormack died on 24 November 1940, aged 78 years, followed by his brother John Papley Cormack on 23 August 1956, aged 84 years. The death of John Papley Cormack, in the centenary year of his parents' marriage, was the final link with Westray Villa and the young woman who had left her homeland in 1852. Probate was granted to John's children – John Henry Cormack of 197 Station Street, North Carlton, and Florence Jane Phoebe Cormack of 248 Canning Street, North Carlton. The house changed ownership in 1960, ending 80 years of continuous ownership and occupancy by the Cormack family. Over the years, the house has undergone some modifications, but the original brick structure and the name "Westray Villa" on the parapet remain essentially the same.38,39,40,41,42
Phoebe's final resting place is in Melbourne General Cemetery, not far from Westray Villa in North Carlton. She and William are buried in an unmarked grave in the Presbyterian compartment, together with their children Jane, George and Phoebe. Backing onto this grave is another of more recent burial, marked out and identified only by a number, where Rachel, Jane Papley, Jessie, James and William Donald are buried. John Papley Cormack is buried in a separate unmarked grave with his wife Florence Matilda Holyoake, who he married in 1908. Nearby there is an elaborate monument to the Orkney family, a reminder that others in this sea of graves might share their ancestral roots with the Orkney Islands of Scotland.43,44
In the aftermath of the Ticonderoga tragedy, questions were asked and blame was laid variously on the Colonial Land and Emigration Commission (for chartering the ship), the ship owners (for seeking profit at the expense of passenger health and safety), and, by no less a personage than Lieutenant Governor Charles La Trobe, the passengers themselves for not keeping their quarters clean. A positive outcome from the tragedy was that double-deck ships were no longer to be used for emigrant transport and passenger numbers were restricted, particularly for infants and young children, who had higher mortality rates. The Ticonderoga had its final voyage, in either 1872 or 1879, when it was wrecked off the coast of India.45,46
A permanent quarantine (or sanitary) station was established at Point Nepean – the area having been fortuitously selected for the purpose some months prior to the arrival of the Ticonderoga – and it provided an essential public health service for nearly a century and a half, by containing infectious diseases before they reached the populated areas of Victoria. In the chaotic early days of setting up the station, able-bodied stonemasons and carpenters amongst the passengers of the Ticonderoga were engaged to build structures to house passengers and staff. Some of these tradesmen elected to stay and settle in the area, as work was guaranteed and the pay was good. The area where the Ticonderoga passengers first came ashore in 1852 became known as Ticonderoga Bay. This bay is now a dolphin sanctuary and the sociable marine mammals frolic in the waters once sailed by the plague ship Ticonderoga.47,48
Finally, we return to the ancient island of Westray. In 2009, an archaeological dig uncovered a 4 cm carved Neolithic figurine, the first one of its kind to be found in Scotland and the earliest depiction of a human face found in the United Kingdom. The stone figurine was dubbed the "Westray Wife" and, in the local parlance, the term "wife" can mean any woman, regardless of her marital status. Phoebe Papley was a young Westray woman when she left her homeland in 1852 and she became a Westray wife when she married William Cormack in 1856. The connection between the "Westray Wife" and the house in Canning Street is tenuous, but intriguing.49
A Note on Sources:
Information on the history of the house known as Westray Villa is taken from Research into 248 Canning Street, North Carlton. (National Trust of Australia. Victoria) This document includes some biographical information on the Papley and Cormack families and, where sources exist, these records have been cross-checked with immigration and shipping records; birth, death and marriage records; census records ; probate documents ; land titles and electoral rolls.
Michael Veitch's 2018 publication Hell ship : The true story of the plague ship Ticonderoga, one of the most calamitous voyages in Australian history gives a detailed account of life and death on board the Ticonderoga, and the events that led to the tragedy.
The Port Fairy Historical Society provided information on the family of James Papley and their assistance is gratefully acknowledged.
1 Scotland, Select Births and Baptisms, 1564-1950
2 Scotland Census 1841
3 Scotland Census 1851
4 Assisted and Unassisted Passenger Lists, 1839–1923
5 According to the Scottish Girls Names website, the names "Jessie" and "Janet" are synonymous.
6 Michael Veitch. Hell ship : The true story of the plague ship Ticonderoga, one of the most calamitous voyages in Australian history. Allen & Unwin, 2018
7 Scarlet fever and typhus are bacterial diseases, which can now be treated with antibiotics. The mode of typhus transmission via human body lice was not understood until the 20th century.
8 Some sources state that James Papley's infant son James died either during the voyage or in quarantine, but his name does not appear on the list of deaths. The birth of a child named James was registered to James and Jessie Papley at Belfast (Port Fairy) in 1853. James Papley junior's obituary, published in the Port Fairy Gazette of 28 June 1917, states that he was born in the Orkney Islands in 1852.
9 Marten A. Syme. Seeds of a settlement : a perspective of Port Fairy in the second half of the nineteenth century through the surviving buildings and their inhabitants, 1991, p. 134-135
10 Hamilton Spectator, 12 April 1871, p. 4
11 The Age, 17 July 1869, p. 2
12 Victorian birth records confirm that Phoebe Mott was a local girl, born in Belfast in 1851. She would have been about 18 years old at the time of the alleged assault.
13 Scotland Births & Baptisms 1564-1950
14 Pioneer Index. Victoria 1836-1888
15 The births of some of the Cormack children are recorded with the maternal name variations of "Phebe", "Popley" and "Possley".
16 Building ownership and occupancy information on the Faraday Street houses is sourced from Melbourne City Council rate books (Smith and Victoria wards).
17 The Argus 16 May, 1860, p. 6
18 Certificate of title, vol. 367, fol. 258
19 Certificate of title, vol. 1204, fol. 768
20 Notice of Intent, reg. no. 8539, 8 October 1880 (Australian Architectural Index)
21 Melbourne City Council, Victoria Ward, 1881, no. 2538. Note: Bathrooms were sometimes included in the overall room count.
22 Melbourne City Council, Victoria Ward, 1881, no. 2108
24 Australian Electoral Commission
25 Commonwealth Electoral Roll, Division of Northern Melbourne, 1903
26 The Age, 7 April 1897, p. 3
27 The Age, 3 November 1897, p. 8
28 Letters of Administration of William Cormack's estate, 67-101 (1898) (VPRS 28)
29 The Age, 6 October 1900, p. 6
30 Last will and testament of Phoebe Cormack (140-166) (VPRS 7591)
31 Rachel Cormack's date of death is confirmed by Melbourne General Cemetery records.
32 The Age of 21 March 1914, p. 5
33 Port Fairy Gazette, 2 November 1914, p. 2
34 Probate File of Phoebe Cormack, 140-166 (1915) (VPRS 28)
35 Letters of Administration of William Cormack's estate, 172-678 (1920) (VPRS 28)
36 NAA: B2455, PAPLEY LEONARD (National Archives of Australia)
37 James Papley's death notice in Port Fairy Gazette, 28 June 1917, p. 2
38 Jane Papley's occupation is listed as "Ayreshire Needlework" in the Scotland 1861 Census and "Dressmaker" in the Scotland 1881 Census.
39 Dates of death are confirmed by probate documents (where applicable), newspapers notices or Melbourne General Cemetery records.
40 The Age, 16 October 1928, p. 1
41 Certificate of title, vol. 1204, fol. 768
42 Probate File of John Papley Cormack, 508/623 (1956) (VPRS 28)
43 Melbourne General Cemetery records
44 The marriage was reported in The Age, 30 January 1909, p. 5
45 Letter from Governor La Trobe to Sir John Pakington, 26 January 1853, quoted by Michael Veitch in Hell Ship, p. 242.
46 Wikipedia (accessed 14 March 2019) cites the year 1872, while Michael Veitch cites October 1879 in Hell Ship, p. 239.
47 The place name Ticonderoga Bay appeared in newspaper reports and the Victoria Government Gazette from 1853.
48 Wildlife (Marine Mammals) Regulations 2009 (Statutory Rule No. 143/2009)
49 The story behind the Westray Wife
Home | News | About Us | Recollections | Street Names | Small Streets of Carlton | Carlton in the News | Crime in Carlton | Travelling in Carlton | Carlton in the War | Rathdowne Street | Images of Carlton | Publications | Membership | Meetings | Contact Us | Links